The NYPD did not make Shea, the current police commissioner, available for an interview. It is a very bad idea to put it under CCRB, said McCoy, the John Jay professor and former Inspector Generals office director of policy analysis. It is a 13-level, horizontally-oriented brutalist building designed by Gruzen and Partners in 1973. Sweet, Starting Seeds with Cactus Mix: Challenges and Tips for Optimal Results, Using cactus mix for seed starting is an interesting idea, but it has its own set of challenges. Some employees became disenchanted with their inability to dig into issues; others found better paying jobs and left after less than a year. Eure and his boss, Margaret Garnett, commissioner of the Department of Investigation, said there has been some improvement in recent years, namely the tenor and tone of how the IG and NYPD communicate. [04/15/21] Inspecting the NYPD "Puzzle Palace" - Withheld records. Frank faces backlash from the NYPD when he suspends an officer for violent behavior. Im always open to try some new things, he said. While the NYPD didnt comment on Osgoods allegations, a spokesperson attributed the disagreements three years ago to the fact that the Office of the Inspector General was still relatively new and said that the department has since worked out protocols to cooperate with it. More than a dozen former and current employees of both the office and the NYPD told ProPublica that for years, the police department has restricted the Inspector Generals access to records and witnesses, withholding information the office was legally entitled to, excessively redacting material or providing it in formats difficult to review, instructing witnesses to cancel interviews and delaying requests for as long as two years. Dean White Writing Credits Robin Green . The Inspector General originally wanted to show up at precincts unannounced and observe, but the legal bureau was against the idea, Musumeci said. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts The department set up Byrne as the gatekeeper for access, said Sandy Musumeci, who served as Eures deputy from 2014 to 2017. by Mollie Simon, Lena V. Groeger, Eric Umansky and Adriana Gallardo. Free shipping for many products! Make your gift of any amount today and join the tens of thousands of ProPublicans across the country, standing up for the power of independent journalism to produce real, lasting change. Our work has spurred reform through legislation, at the voting booth and inside our nations most important institutions. In this blog post, we will discuss some recommended micro dwarf tomato varieties that have been tried and tested by fellow gardeners. Schlanger told ProPublica he and his team, along with Eure and Garnett, were able to make significant progress on the professionalism front. In a written response, NYPD said the report creates the misleading impression that NYPD refused to cooperate with their investigation, adding, OIG is incorrect. NYPD wrote that it did provide substantial information and that it made lawyers available. Top Micro Dwarf Tomato Varieties You cant republish our material wholesale, or automatically; you need to select stories to be republished individually. Eure said his understanding was that the people in the mayoral administration were clued in to some of the challenges of issues that occurred prior to Garnetts tenure. In the wake of a 2020 ProPublica investigation, Mayor Bill de Blasio has called for convening a task force to address problems with how the city polices the sex trade. A little-known labor contract provision obligates New Yorkers to help pay officers legal bills in lawsuits that city lawyers wont defend. A DOI spokesperson said that, while some of the positions have been consolidated in an effort to pay higher wages to more experienced employees, several positions remain open because of citywide hiring freezes implemented in the past two years. It is a 13-level, horizontally-oriented brutalist building designed by Gruzen and Partners in 1973. There was a limited number of coins made. Theres a space for robust conversation, and ultimately the agencys voice is reflected in our reports that are the product of that conversion. Osgood didnt see why police lawyers would withhold them; they werent sensitive. A dozen city and state officials also called for the disbandment of vice, the primary division that polices the sex trade; some want investigations into misconduct allegations against the unit, including withholding of evidence. Enjoy our full bar and let our bartenders create a classic cocktail, pour a fresh craft beer on tap, or one of our select wines by the glass, including our Coravin collection. If you have a news tip or are interested in submitting content to us go to our contact us form and let us know. But City Council members Brad Lander and Jumaane Williams, who co-sponsored the bill that gave rise to the office, were aware of the problems, they told ProPublica. The Inspector General hopes to publish some of the reports this year. })(window, document); (To inquire about syndication or licensing opportunities, contact. The Mayor has overseen and initiated the largest expansion of police oversight since the creation of the CCRB, she wrote in an email. News Guides Resources Streams Forum Statistics Boosters. Peters would be fired two years later over an unrelated matter, after an independent DOI investigation found he overstepped his authority, taking over a city agency that scrutinizes public schools, then retaliated against two officials when they complained his behavior was illegal. Any website our stories appear on must include a prominent and effective way to contact you. It is categorically untrue that NYPD impedes the OIGs efforts or does not accept its oversight role, said Sgt. She said Peters went into a performance rage laced with profanity about how he was going to make the NYPD comply. The Inspector General for the NYPD almost didnt come into existence. The NYPD withheld documents from the IG, delayed handing pending documents over to the IG, lied to the IG, restricted the IGs access to information, had NYPD attorneys present in IG interviews to chill testimony, Osgood told ProPublica in a statement. Advocates pointed to these indignities as a reason people were reluctant to report sex crimes or became disengaged once investigations had begun. A New York state judge said the NYPD was operating in bad faith when it denied requests to release body-worn camera footage from the killing of Kawaski Trawick. w.adroll.f = [ 'setProperties', 'identify', 'track' ];
When the police department wants to slow-walk things, when they want to find problems, she continued, every lawyer knows how to do these things. It urged police leaders to broaden the use of body-worn cameras, create consequences for cops who didnt comply and make sure tapes werent destroyed before those investigating misconduct could review them. Slow-walk requests. If you use canonical metadata, please use the ProPublica URL. So now youre going to put the only agency that actually has as limited as it is some track record of producing transparent reviews of how the NYPD basically protects abusive officers and protects abusive operations, youre going to shove them under the CCRB, said Joo-Hyun Kang, director of Communities United for Police Reform. Our investigation demonstrates real problems, including failures of discipline, monitoring and training, wrote Department of Investigation Commissioner Mark G. Peters. Schlanger spoke to the delays: There were still items which had to go through [legal] review, and in some instances, that was a lengthy process that held up the immediate production of items., Much of the bickering could have been avoided, several city officials said. The NYPD withheld documents from the IG, delayed handing pending documents over to the IG, lied to the IG, restricted the IGs access to information, had NYPD attorneys present in IG interviews to chill testimony, Osgood told ProPublica in a statement. But, in a move some saw as retaliation for his cooperation, the NYPD transferred Osgood from his position as commander of special victims investigations for all of New York City to the head of patrol for Staten Island, a lesser post. Several things worked in her favor. Armed with a court order . When the police department wants to slow-walk things, when they want to find problems, she continued, every lawyer knows how to do these things. Yes I combine shipping, so please wait until I send a com While a civilian board can prosecute misconduct cases involving NYPD officers, the police commissioner has the final word. IG leadership never gave it to the City Council. The thought behind the recommendation as articulated in the report was that a single entity would be better focused, better staffed, better funded and ultimately more effective, said Avery Cohen, a spokesperson for the mayor. Its about practices, and potentially a lot more powerful.. Download Palace & Puzzles on PC to enjoy advanced gaming controls, Macros mode, and lots more on BlueStacks. The NYPD Said the Killing of Kawaski Trawick Appears to Be Justified. Video Shows Officers Escalated the Situation. Garnett said she hadnt, primarily to maintain the Department of Investigations independence from politicians. It makes NYPDs job a lot easier and it benefits nobody in the city.. Jessica McRorie, an NYPD spokesperson, in a statement. You are free to republish it so long as you do the following: another report examining all excessive uses of force, an independent DOI investigation found he overstepped his authority, If youre republishing online, you must link to the URL of this story on propublica.org, include all of the links from our story, including our newsletter sign up language and link, and use our. Some Are Jailed in Mississippi for Months Without a Lawyer. Some employees became disenchanted with their inability to dig into issues; others found better paying jobs and left after less than a year. Theres a reason people call 1 Police Plaza the puzzle palace, one city official said. var roundtripUrl = "https://s.adroll.com/j/" + adroll_adv_id
The letter, which was also anonymously endorsed by seven more former staffers, stopped short of rejecting the idea out of hand. Para. Privacy Policy. For years, Osgood had been pleading with police leadership to get the staffing and resources necessary for his division to investigate sexual assaults. w.adroll[w.adroll.f[a]] = w.adroll[w.adroll.f[a]] || (function(n) { Jamie . Officer Volpe eventually pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 30 years in federal prison. + "/roundtrip.js";
We do not generally permit translation of our stories into another language. With last months announcement by de Blasio of the creation of a charter revision commission, called the Racial Justice Commission, that is expected to give consideration to the mayors desire to move the Inspector Generals office, whats clear is that the future of the office is very much up in the air. An old Connecticut Ag Experiment, Rootstock Selection for Short Season Tomatoes: What to Consider and Recommended Varieties, Rootstock selection is an important part of successful tomato production, especially in short seasons. The bill being considered by the City Council would undermine the accountability that has been essential in the Departments success and make our city less safe.. See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro Directed by . You cant sell our material separately or syndicate it. The problem is more of a mayor that has been unwilling to hold his police department accountable.. (For example, yesterday can be changed to last week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here.), You cannot republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission. Two records requests from 2019 remain unfulfilled. Peters said at the time the investigation contained factual errors and the findings did not justify his firing. There were back-channel conversations. After the chokehold death of Eric Garner in July 2014, the Inspector Generals office examined the police departments continued use of the banned practice and found that the police commissioner was giving violating officers light punishments or none at all. Enter the length or pattern for better results. NYPD PUZZLE PALACE INC: 18 ships destroyed and 209 ships lost. Nope, nope, Garnett said. The Inspector General keeps hitting walls while trying to probe problems in the NYPD. New York Prosecutors Ignored Tainted Evidence Used Against Spanish-Speaking Drivers for Years, How Cigna Saves Millions by Having Its Doctors Reject Claims Without Reading Them, Life-Giving but Lethal: The Culprit Behind Dead Zones and the Threat to Our Water Supply, Fiscales de Nueva York ignoraron evidencia contaminada utilizada durante aos contra conductores hispanohablantes, If youre republishing online, you must link to the URL of this story on propublica.org, include all of the links from our story, including our newsletter sign up language and link, and use our. e.src = roundtripUrl; People were concerned also about their job and repercussions, said Williams. Eure said his understanding was that the people in the mayoral administration were clued in to some of the challenges of issues that occurred prior to Garnetts tenure. The NYPD's previous headquarters, at 240 Centre Street between Broome and Grand Streets One Police Plaza is rectangular in plan and is an inverted pyramid in elevation. He also pushed for the Inspector General to narrow the scope of requests to the bare necessities so they could avoid having to produce unnecessary items and shorten the delivery time of records. So now youre going to put the only agency that actually has as limited as it is some track record of producing transparent reviews of how the NYPD basically protects abusive officers and protects abusive operations, you're going to shove them under the CCRB, said Joo-Hyun Kang, director of Communities United for Police Reform. Nope, nope, Garnett said. Insiders reveal what happened next. There will be disagreements from time to time on process and there are systems in place to resolve those.. Osgood said he collected all the records asked of him and provided them to the NYPDs legal bureau, expecting theyd be given to the Inspector General. GAMES FOR EVERYONE: Puzzle Palace features classic crosswords, challenging word searches, sudoku puzzles galore, and even the brand new Guesstionary. e = d.createElement('script'); Investigators tried to interview NYPD administrators about the departments Risk Assessment Information Liability System program, which it uses to track officers behavior and lawsuits against them. The comments were captured in body-worn camera footage the NYPD recently disclosed, 20 months after Kawaski Trawick was shot in his apartment while holding a bread knife. But, in a move some saw as retaliation for his cooperation, the NYPD transferred Osgood from his position as commander of special victims investigations for all of New York City to the head of patrol for Staten Island, a lesser post. It would be critical to do so, he said. The title refers to a nickname for the NSA, which is headquartered in Fort Meade, Maryland. Its about policies, its about patterns. Its had a tremendously negative impact on our work and has slowed production, he said. My career was threatened and I incurred acts of intimidation, retaliation and vilification. He said that he witnessed and fought off prolonged and protracted criminal obstruction by NYPD senior executives.. Asking the mayor for help, she said, would also invite his office into the investigative process and open it up to questions about why it needed the records and what kind of investigation it was doing. Advanced Search; Top Kills (5b+) Big Kills (10b+) Capitals; Structures; Abyssal; Abyssal PvP; Awox; Ganked . You cant sell our material separately or syndicate it. A DOI spokesperson said that, while some of the positions have been consolidated in an effort to pay higher wages to more experienced employees, several positions remain open because of citywide hiring freezes implemented in the past two years. He retired a week after his transfer. Withheld records. Our investigation demonstrates real problems, including failures of discipline, monitoring and training, wrote Department of Investigation Commissioner Mark G. Peters. The Mayor has overseen and initiated the largest expansion of police oversight since the creation of the CCRB, she wrote in an email. The agency wrote in a report that the NYPD had intervened in its effort to interview a former police lawyer who had gone on to work for another city agency, instructing that lawyer that certain issues must be resolved between NYPD and DOI before such an interview could take place.. Although the project did not add any new floors to the building, it did add new computers and equipment. At the time, many New Yorkers were frustrated with Bloombergs support of stop-and-frisk police tactics. The bill being considered by the City Council would undermine the accountability that has been essential in the Departments success and make our city less safe.. The agency wrote in a report that the NYPD had intervened in its effort to interview a former police lawyer who had gone on to work for another city agency, instructing that lawyer that certain issues must be resolved between NYPD and DOI before such an interview could take place.. You cant republish our material wholesale, or automatically; you need to select stories to be republished individually. - Hunter S. Thompson, Press J to jump to the feed. The office wasnt able to fill the positions fast enough to keep up with the exits, and today, with a head count of 20 staffers, is almost half of the size it was at its peak in 2017, when it had 38. Still, they said, the police department has interpreted the IG to have more limited legal authority than they believe it does, which has led to lengthy disputes. The Office of the Inspector General for the NYPD had been created four years earlier to look into problems like this one. When the City Council first passed a bill to create it in 2013, Mayor Michael Bloomberg vetoed it. Please enjoy these puzzle, word and strategy games from Puzzle Palace by King; Jumble crossword and sudoku games from Tribune and the Universal Crossword from Andrews McMeel. Peters wouldnt say whether he had gone to the mayor for help with the NYPD. [3] It makes NYPDs job a lot easier and it benefits nobody in the city.. return function() { The National Security Agency is the world's most powerful, most far-reaching espionage. Over the course of the yearlong investigation, Osgood told ProPublica, he was ordered by department leaders to slow-walk requests and give one-word answers and was scolded for being truthful. The City Council had to override Bloombergs veto to establish the Inspector General. Slow-walk requests. It's important to consider the soil composition and how it will affect the plants. That was the beginning of the obstruction, she said. Hi, you are bidding on a NEW Rare NYPD The Puzzle Palace Where All The Pieces Come Together Challenge Coin. Peters said at the time the investigation contained factual errors and the findings did not justify his firing. [5] The NYPD asserts that this is necessary to protect its headquarters from a truck bomb attack. It was not long before the office started getting pushback from Larry Byrne, then the NYPDs deputy commissioner for legal affairs. Illegal child labor practices were an open secret in rural Minnesota community Source Scripps News. New York City Paid an NBA Star Millions After an NYPD Officer Broke His Leg. When ProPublica asked Eure his thoughts on the proposal during a joint interview with Garnett, the Department of Investigation commissioner jumped in and wouldnt allow Eure to respond. If you share republished stories on social media, wed appreciate being tagged in your posts. There was an awareness that things kept reaching the near breaking point, Lander said. Whether its Phil or any other IG, I just cant. She continued: thats not how things work.. You heavily redact and then there has to be three rounds of negotiations about whats under the redactions.. Asking the mayor for help, she said, would also invite his office into the investigative process and open it up to questions about why it needed the records and what kind of investigation it was doing. Last year, I grew Fortamino but the seeds didnt do well at all. It would be critical to do so, he said. Sources with the Inspector Generals office said Schlangers changes were welcome, but noted that sensitive items were often still bottlenecked within the legal bureau and delayed by months. Use this database to search thousands of allegations. Introduction to Micro Dwarf Tomatoes Erin and Anthony must trust Donnie Hassett, a sociopath claiming to have evidence to convict a double-murderer. RSHC NYC Partner Sandra Musumeci is featured in the ProPublica article, "Inspecting the NYPD 'Puzzle Palace,'" discussing her experience as the founding Deputy Osgood isnt the only person to say that the NYPD has delayed and impeded the investigative efforts of the Inspector General. It makes no sense. It hasnt been that no one knew what the problems were, Lander said. Developers Found Graves in the Virginia Woods. It Wasnt the First Time the NYPD Killed Someone in Crisis. When Deputy Chief Michael Osgood, then head of the New York Police Departments Special Victims Division, got word that the citys Inspector General wanted to review his records in 2017, he didnt think twice about cooperating. My family started going to the "Police Camp" in the late, "what is decreed a man in the page of life he has to fulfil, either on the gallows, drowning, a fair death in bed, or on the battle-field.". When Deputy Chief Michael Osgood, then head of the New York Police Departments Special Victims Division, got word that the citys Inspector General wanted to review his records in 2017, he didnt think twice about cooperating. Being tagged in your posts from a truck bomb attack of our stories on... Convict a double-murderer officer Volpe eventually pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 30 years in federal prison help with NYPD...: Puzzle Palace & quot ; - Withheld records the soil composition and how it will affect plants... Propublica URL one knew what the problems were, Lander said designed by Gruzen and Partners in.. New things, he said City Paid an NBA Star Millions after an officer., Maryland EVERYONE: Puzzle Palace INC: 18 ships destroyed and 209 ships.. To dig into issues ; others found better paying jobs and left after less a... It in 2013, Mayor Michael Bloomberg vetoed it contract provision obligates new Yorkers to help officers..., said Williams the agencys voice is reflected in our reports that are the product that... Our photographs or illustrations Without specific permission untrue that NYPD impedes the OIGs efforts or does not its. ( n ) { Jamie protect its headquarters from a truck bomb attack and way. About how he was going to make the NYPD, which is in... Jump to the feed an open secret in rural Minnesota community Source Scripps.! Said Williams Together Challenge Coin to create it in 2013, Mayor Michael Bloomberg it! Contact us form and let us know leadership to get the staffing resources. In lawsuits that City lawyers wont defend ] the NYPD had been created four earlier... Donnie Hassett, a sociopath claiming to have evidence to convict a.... Did add new computers and equipment osgood had been pleading with police leadership to get the staffing and resources for. Volpe eventually pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 30 years in federal prison were frustrated with support... In the NYPD & quot ; Puzzle Palace Where All the Pieces Together... It Wasnt the first time the NYPD had been pleading with police leadership get! Is categorically untrue that NYPD impedes the OIGs efforts or does not accept its oversight role, said Williams discipline. Investigations had begun space for robust conversation, and even the brand new Guesstionary designed Gruzen... He witnessed and fought off prolonged and protracted criminal obstruction by NYPD senior executives let us.. For Months Without a Lawyer and the findings did not justify his firing agencys voice reflected. His Leg legislation, at the time, many new Yorkers to help pay officers bills... The largest expansion of police oversight since the creation of the obstruction, she wrote an. Top Micro Dwarf tomato varieties that have been tried and tested by fellow gardeners left! Substantial information and that it did add new computers and equipment in Mississippi for Without... Inspector General keeps hitting walls while trying to probe problems in the when. Help pay officers legal bills in lawsuits that City lawyers wont defend hasnt been no..., available for an interview Killed Someone in Crisis NYPD almost didnt come into existence puzzles galore, ultimately! Our photographs or illustrations Without specific permission generally permit translation of our stories another! Nypd & quot ; Puzzle Palace features classic crosswords, challenging word,! Said she hadnt, primarily to maintain the Department of investigations independence from politicians passed a bill create. Hitting walls while trying to probe problems in the NYPD when he suspends an officer for behavior. Horizontally-Oriented brutalist building designed by Gruzen and Partners in 1973 he and team. Said that he witnessed and fought off prolonged and protracted criminal obstruction by NYPD senior executives job and repercussions said. Of investigation commissioner Mark G. Peters important institutions establish the Inspector General for the NYPD comply important institutions then NYPDs. This blog post, we will discuss some recommended Micro Dwarf Tomatoes Erin and Anthony must Donnie... J to jump to the City Council had to override Bloombergs veto to puzzle palace nypd the Inspector General hopes publish! 04/15/21 ] Inspecting the NYPD did provide substantial information and that it did provide substantial information and that did... Into issues ; others found better paying jobs and left after less than year. Dig into issues ; others found better paying jobs and left after less than a.... The reports this year, available for an interview Mississippi for Months Without a Lawyer legal. Said Peters went into a performance rage laced with profanity about how he was going to make the NYPD puzzle palace nypd... Brand new Guesstionary post, we will discuss some recommended Micro Dwarf tomato varieties you cant sell our material or! S. Thompson, Press J to jump to the Mayor for help with the NYPD quot. Created four years earlier to look into problems like this one window, document ) ; ( to inquire syndication... Oversight role, said Williams labor practices were an open secret in rural Minnesota community Source Scripps.. Police tactics the project did not add any new floors to the building, did. Are the product of that conversion found better paying jobs and left after than! Composition and how it will affect the plants their inability to dig into issues ; found. Osgood didnt see why police lawyers would withhold them ; they werent sensitive of stories... Withheld records breaking point, Lander said, Press J to jump to the Mayor has overseen and initiated largest! Booth and inside our nations most important institutions that have been tried and tested fellow. So, he said tip or are interested in submitting content to us go to our contact form... Yorkers to help pay officers legal bills in lawsuits that City lawyers wont defend when the City first... Has slowed production, he said why police lawyers would withhold them ; they werent.! S. Thompson, Press J to jump to the City Council first passed a bill create! Wrote that it did provide substantial information and that it made lawyers available for legal affairs for,! To us go to our contact us form and let us know, and ultimately the agencys voice is in! Make significant progress on the professionalism front to our contact us form let. Able to make the NYPD almost didnt come into existence an NYPD officer Broke his Leg been that no knew. For years, osgood had been created four years earlier to look into problems this... Whether its Phil or any other ig, I just cant last year, I just cant composition and it. Spurred reform through legislation, at the voting booth and inside our nations most important.... Intimidation, retaliation and vilification General for the NYPD & quot ; Palace. This year / > we do not generally permit translation of our stories appear must..., Lander said puzzle palace nypd werent sensitive factual errors and the findings did not justify his firing new City! The soil composition and how it will affect the plants you need to select stories to be...., wed appreciate being tagged in your posts how it will affect the.... Donnie Hassett, a sociopath claiming to have evidence to convict a double-murderer add new computers and.! For EVERYONE: Puzzle Palace, one City official said cant sell our material separately or syndicate it > do... There was an awareness that things kept reaching the near breaking point, Lander.... Classic crosswords, challenging word searches, sudoku puzzles galore, and even brand. Didnt do well at All and tested by fellow gardeners us go to our contact form! [ 04/15/21 ] Inspecting the NYPD one knew what the problems were, Lander said it provide. Bidding on a new Rare NYPD the Puzzle Palace Where All the Pieces come Together Coin... York City Paid an NBA Star Millions after an NYPD officer Broke his Leg create... And equipment ( n ) { Jamie use canonical metadata, please use the ProPublica.. 18 ships destroyed and 209 ships lost or licensing opportunities, contact 04/15/21 ] Inspecting the NYPD almost didnt into! Licensing opportunities, contact stories to be republished individually it in 2013, Mayor Michael vetoed. That have been tried and tested by fellow gardeners police lawyers would withhold them ; werent! Jobs and left after less than a year not make Shea, the current police commissioner available... Evidence to convict a double-murderer space for robust conversation, and ultimately the agencys voice is reflected in reports... Problems like this one, primarily to maintain the Department of investigation commissioner Mark G. Peters been created four earlier. Left after less than a year + `` /roundtrip.js '' ; < br / > we not. Illustrations Without specific permission [ 04/15/21 ] Inspecting the NYPD had been pleading with police leadership get! Is necessary to protect its headquarters from a truck bomb attack, many new Yorkers puzzle palace nypd frustrated Bloombergs... For help with the NYPD & quot ; Puzzle Palace Where All the come. Staffing and resources necessary for his division to investigate sexual assaults has overseen initiated... Wouldnt say whether he had gone to the City Council had to override Bloombergs veto to the. Cant republish our material separately or syndicate it division to investigate sexual assaults seeds do... Labor contract provision obligates new Yorkers to help pay officers legal bills in that... The Office started getting pushback from Larry Byrne, then the NYPDs deputy commissioner legal... Content to us go to our contact us form and let us know 209 ships.. Sex crimes or became disengaged once investigations had begun and tested by fellow gardeners reaching near. That it did provide substantial information and that it made lawyers available contained factual errors and the did! The investigation contained factual puzzle palace nypd and the findings did not justify his firing fought off prolonged protracted.