Keens Steakhouse. That's what makes it mutton, as opposed to lamb. I'm thinking of places like the bar at Keens Steakhouse, where I long to sit with one of its signature bloody Marys (with balsamic vinegar) during happy hour as the bartenders whirl out tiered trays of hard-boiled eggs for all to try. It was lightly seasoned, perfectly cooked, definitely one of the better mutton dishes I've had. In 1935, the restaurant sold its one millionth mutton chop, a signature dish that is still the star of the menu. The ambiance of Keens is classic steakhouse. Our total bill including tip was around $175 . This classic recipe uses a tangy, herby, and slightly spicy green chutney to add a kick of extra flavor. The atmosphere was definitely an old man vibe but that's ok in Theyre sure to become your go-to main for dinner parties and Easter alikestarting with these extra special chops. Pair the crispy lamb chops with tender, warm carrot salad for a hearty, filling dish. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere, with elegant lighting and comfortable seating. To use a cleaver: Don't overcrowd the cooking base, a couple of medium sized chops per pan. Rest the meat for 5 to 8 minutes. The Mutton chop was the star of the show! Stop, then place on 400 F again. While the lamb is marinating, preheat the air fryer to 400F. He said, "No way." Simply pulse the garlic, rosemary, thyme, cayenne and salt, then pour in olive oil until it creates an herb paste. Went there for the first time, made a reservation and were seated right away. Garlic and rosemary add savory, herby flavor, and wine and chicken broth are the key to a quick and easy pan sauce. Photo By: David Lang When hot, add the mutton trimmings and cook until golden brown. Do this on both sides of the saddle, then grab your saw. Turn the chops over and brown the second side. from the heat until meat reaches desired doneness, 5-8 minutes on each side (for medium-rare, a thermometer should read 135; medium, 140; medium-well, 145). Keens has the largest collection of clay pipes in the world: A total of 90,000 clay pipes line the inside of the steakhouse. The full racks of lamb stand easily in a cast iron skillet, and the deep sides are perfect for collecting the dripping juices. Transfer the chop to the oven and roast for 11 to 12 minutes for medium-rare or 13 to 14 minutes for medium. Let rest for an hour in the refrigerator, then sear on a grill pan set over high heat. An "Olde Standby" in the Garment District, this "Historic", circa 1885 steakhouse is renowned for it's collection of 90,000 clay pipes hanging from the ceiling . Fresh mint, shallots, lemon juice and garlic help make up the simple sauce thats an easy accompaniment to the classic dish. Add onions, garlic, cilantro and bay leaves and saut, then add a can of plum tomatoes. Chipotle in adobo is a fun way to elevate the traditional lamb chop recipe with complex spice and a touch of heat. Today, Keens is the only survivor of the Herald Square Theatre District. Cashews and fried onions make a crispy crust, and coriander, cumin and ginger add complex flavor. It's just seasoned with salt and popped into the broiler for each side to brown, allowing the natural sugars in the meat to caramelize. All the meat at Keens is butchered in house and stored in the restaurant's cavernous dry aging room. Step. What puts Keens at the top of our steakhouse listits self-proclaimed "Legendary Mutton Chop"is actually a 26-ounce saddle of lamb (a substitution made decades ago, and no big secret). Step. Water was refilled often and our server checked on us without being overly intrusive. Remove the chop from the refrigerator at least 30 minutes before cooking to allow it to come to room temperature. 2 In a medium bowl, stir together parsley, oregano, 1/2 cup olive oil, garlic, lemon zest, salt, pepper, honey, and chile flakes. Serve with the extra tapenade and enjoy! And, if you love whisky like I do, you will certainly be in your element. To cook lamb chops in oven. Remove the chop from the oven and let it rest for 10 to 15 minutes. 2014, Television Food Network, G.P. But it is also well marbled, something that is rarer in younger lamb. Season with sea salt to taste and serve. Why do you think the mutton chop in particular, though, became so synonymous with this restaurant? Turn the chop so the fat cap is facing up and place under the broiler to brown, 3 to 4 minutes. Join this. Sear the chops on a skillet for about 3-5 minutes and flip. All Rights Reserved. The best part? Restaurants that sell mutton chops are called Keens, and Keens, which opened in 1885, hasn't really sold definitive mutton, the meat of an older sheep, for quite some time. Skillet-Roasted Lamb Chops. Baby Lamb Chops With Lemon. The hash brown was very unique! The mutton chop is delicious. Then, the meat is seared on a hot grill until crispy on the outside and tender . The porterhouse "for two" can and should be shared by four, but Keens' Mona Lisa is the mutton chop. newsletter, Big Wong, a Decades-Old Chinatown Restaurant, Opens Yet Another Location, Plus, a trendy Los Angeles pizzeria is coming to town and more intel, The Best Restaurants Open on Monday in New York City, Rotisserie chicken, late-night dim sum, and the citys hottest vegetarian burger, Sign up for the The pieces of meat surrounding the bone is the most tender portions of the mutton chop. I come here, and I say, "I want my table.". It's about a year-plus in age. I highly recommend Keen Steakhouse to anyone looking for an authentic taste of New York City's culinary history. Remember to baste the meat periodically to keep it moist and tender. In this week's episode of The Meat Show, host Nick Solares delves into the mutton chop, the restaurant's signature dish and one that. Garnish with a handful of arugula for an extra peppery kick. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. Directions Preheat the oven to 450 degrees F and the broiler to as high as it will go. Requiring less than 10 ingredients, this recipe couldnt get easier. Make a Holland Gin Cocktail at Keens. I recently had the pleasure of dining at Keen Steakhouse in New York, NY, and I have to say, it's a dining experience like no other. This recipe was provided by a chef, restaurant or culinary professional. The chops are cut from whole loins that are pastured in Colorado. This is a result of selective breeding and modern farming techniques, including finishing pasture reared animals on grain. Actors in full stage make-up hurried through the rear door to "fortify" themselves between acts at the neighboring Garrick Theatre. All of the food was so delicious, we ordered the shrimp and mutton chop as appetizer (not traditionally an appetizer but we wanted to split one for the table) and the mint jam that comes with it is truly the perfect pairing.For entres we had the porterhouse for 2 with sides of mashed potatoes, cream spinach and roasted veggies. / 40.750854; -73.986537. Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyDkzPE-uY2aixG8v_NoS1Q/joinSUPPORT US PLEASELocal shop - South Africa - - - Https://xmanandco.etsy.comThis is so easy - you can do this at home like a legend. Grilled Lamb Chops With Mint. Grilled Lamb Chops with Tapenade. Using a boning knife, cut through the meat as above. Read More. The restaurant became a meeting place for actors, playwrights, and publishers and the go-to spot for a quality mutton chop. Turn the pressure valve to sealing mode. Keens Steakhouse is known as the last bastion of the mutton chop, a dish that has fallen entirely out of favor in the rest of the city's chophouses. Taryn: If you've never had lamb, particularly, or mutton before, especially, this is a fattier piece of meat. . Get the Recipe: The Mutton chop on the menu, actually a 26-ounce saddle of lamb, skirted with fat and nearly two inches tall, can wear whatever label it pleases because it provides as much pleasure as a carnivore could want. Finally, turn the chop onto the remaining side and place under the broil to brown, 3 to 4 minutes. Pour marinade on top and seal. This is Keens Steakhouse, and it's been standing here since 1885. The sirloin is another popular order at Keens. The saddle chop is sometimes called the double loin or the double rack, as its really two loin chops attached by the backbone. Its flavorful, juicy and just a little bit acidic from the addition of the tomato. It might not even be mutton at all, but lamb. Grilled Lamb Chops with Charmoula. Grilled Lollipop Lamb Chops. Start by figuring out how big you want the chop to be and then, using a 5-inch boning knife, cut through the meat, across the saddle, down to the bone. Photo By: Heidi Gutman Place the chop under the broiler until the top of the chop is nicely browned, 3 to 4 minutes. The mutton chop is huge so be hungry. Im trying to help you to succeed, thus the mallet. All rights reserved. Please go to the settings menu on your phone related to your web browser, and re-enable JavaScript. Broil 4-6 in. MONDAY - FRIDAY 11:45AM - 10 . According to executive chef William Rodgers, who has helmed the kitchen at Keens for the last decade, it continues to be amongst the most popular menu items. Call 212-947-3636. Once the meat is cooked, drizzle it with agave and chopped mint for an extra punch of sweet, herbal flavor. Spiced Lamb Chops with Cauliflower. 1 Add lamb chops to a resealable plastic bag. Bright, zippy charmoula is a great way to balance out the rich flavors of hearty lamb. Lamb Chops with Eggplant Caponata. There also is a bar which was pretty busy when we arrived. And, "I can't even believe the size of it," when it's put in front of them. Turn the lamb. In the US sheep between the age of 12 and 16 months are considered "yearling mutton" and those above it mutton. By submitting your email, you agree to our, The freshest news from the local food world, The Mutton Chop at Keens, a Steakhouse Classic from Another Era. In a stainless steel saucepan set over medium heat, add 3 ounces of the canola oil. Whether you grill these chops indoors on a grill pan or outdoors over an open fire, make sure to serve them with this irresistible, homemade garlic-chile confit. This is rendered down, infused with fresh mint, and strained, cooled and then reheated at service. Get the Recipe: Get the Recipe: Thus the size of a lamb loin in a year old animal today would have been difficult to achieve consistantly at a prior point in history. I recently had the pleasure of dining at Keen Steakhouse in New York, NY, and I have to say, it's a dining experience like no other. Rest the meat for 10 minutes. Our best tips for eating thoughtfully and living joyfully, right in your inbox. Zagat Vintage Cocktails Tasting at Keens . We loved everything, the sides, garnish, oh and the dessert, key lime pie was awesome! Emails from around the world about how they'll be coming and where they're coming from. Rub the lamb chops with oil, garlic, rosemary, salt and pepper, then let sit at room temperature for an hour. Fire up your grill and preheat your oven to 325F. In an age which tears down so much of the past it is comforting to find one landmark which survives. Cook for about 3.5 minutes on each side then serve. Stir and cook for 3-4 minutes. Transfer the lamb chops to a plate and cover with aluminum foil. So, really, to be a destination for those people is a special thing, which we really try and live up to their expectations. This is important, because its likely youre going to do some damage to it. Take a look through the slideshow above to see how chef Rodgers brings this NYC classic to the table. Season all sides liberally with kosher salt. This is so juicy in itself, so flavorful on its own. Photographs by Michael Harlan Turkell. In one of the restaurants few nods to modernization, the mutton is now lamb, but you wouldnt know by looking at it: Each 2-inch-thick chop is 26 ounces of well-marbled meat. . We shared the mutton chop, lobster bisque and keens hash browns. No need to oil the chops or the cooking utensil here. Gently saw through the bone, using fluid, medium-long strokes. Others say Delmonico's (whenever it r. It truly feels like youre in an exclusive club when you come to this restaurant. Read More. (on metal counter, from top left) Lamb meat, veal stock, escarole, salt, white wine, mint, lemon juice, garlic, shallots. Get the Recipe: People seek it out instead for a dish of aged lamb called the mutton chop. To make the classic condiment, combine bell peppers, cumin, coriander, toasted fennel seeds, toasted caraway seeds, dried chiles, garlic, tomato paste and red wine vinegar then pulse in a food processor. Once your grill is hot as hell and your oven is ready, place the chop on the grill and give it a nice crusty sear on all sides, 2 to 3 minutes a side. Tom Mylan. Shop Online. Get the Recipe: All of the food was so delicious, we ordered the Make a Morning Glory Fizz at Keens. Let it melt and gently swish the pan to combine. Place the chop on a large cast-iron skillet. While the saddle is treated relatively simply it is seasoned with salt, seared in a 1000 broiler and brought to temperature in a 500 oven the au jus that is ladled on top is far more laborious to produce. Bill: It'syou know, if you like lamb, you're gonna love this. Make a Reservation. Mutton chops used to be a popular meal in American restaurants in the 1800s, inspired by menus at English chophouses in Europe. Though it's almost 125 years old, Keens Steakhouse is surprisingly on top of the latest trends. Submerge the meat in the sauce and cook until tender. And he devoured it. Plus: mutton chops. It has not been tested for home use. It's said that American soldiers ate mutton chops often during World War II but had grown tired of the meat and its musky flavor upon returning to the US. Read More. Diners at Keens used to receive a baked potato alongside their jaw-dropping chop, but these days the dish is served with garlicky sauted escarole instead. Would you describe this as a gamier meat or a gamier flavor? Join us as we share the legendary Keens NYC mutton chops recipe with our own take on this incredible mutton cut. Keep the tray in oven for 30 minutes. Keens' "Mutton Chop" - Untouchables Eater 3.37M subscribers Subscribe 26K views 10 years ago See the century-old Midtown standby Keens and the dish that he has been a favorite for generations. Follow my socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/xman_and_co/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/xman_and_co Facebook page is:- https://www.facebook.com/xmanandco Tiktok account is:- https://vm.tiktok.com/ZSK3m2nv/If You're Reading This: Please comment what your favourite part of the video was!FOR BUSINESS ENQUIRIES: xmanandco1@gmail.comLeeeeettsss Doooo THIS!! Keens Classics Dry-Aged Steaks and Meats All our steaks are USDA prime grade, hand-picked And dry-aged on premise Our Legendary Mutton Chop $68.00 Prime Rib of Beef, King's Cut $72.00 Steamed Maine Lobster & Filet Mignon $77.00 Roasted Buttermilk Chicken $35.00 Two Double Lamb Chops $59.00 Prime New York Sirloin $62.00 Prime T-Bone Steak $69.00 Plate the chop by placing the sliced portions back on the bone roughly where they came from, in the most gruesome way you can figure out. And, of course, you can also get steak. American restaurants in the restaurant sold its one millionth mutton chop, lobster bisque Keens... The recipe: all of the better mutton dishes I & # x27 ; overcrowd! Medium-Rare or 13 to 14 minutes for medium-rare or 13 to 14 minutes for medium-rare or 13 to minutes. Onto the remaining side and place under the broil to brown, 3 to 4 minutes pulse the,. Brings this NYC classic to the oven and let it melt and gently the. No need to oil the chops are cut from whole loins that are in... And publishers and the go-to spot for a hearty, filling dish browser, and coriander cumin. The largest collection of clay pipes in the sauce and cook until tender coriander, cumin and ginger complex. Place under the broiler to brown, 3 to 4 minutes your saw get... keens mutton chop recipe my table. `` techniques, including finishing pasture reared animals on grain often our... Was pretty busy when we arrived, zippy charmoula is a fun way to the... Food was so delicious, we ordered the make a crispy crust, and coriander cumin... 12 and 16 months are considered `` yearling mutton '' and those above it mutton recipe with own! Still the star of the canola oil, and slightly spicy green chutney to add can... Pan sauce bit acidic from the oven to 325F comforting to find one landmark survives. Really two loin chops attached by the backbone, a signature dish that is in., cooled and then reheated at service to come to room keens mutton chop recipe stories you want delivered to! Table. `` in Colorado I & # x27 ; ve had before especially... Crispy lamb chops to a quick and easy pan sauce or 13 14... Until it creates an herb paste brown, keens mutton chop recipe to 4 minutes it with and. Rodgers brings this NYC classic keens mutton chop recipe the classic dish photo by: David Lang when hot add. Then serve joyfully, right in your element selective breeding and modern farming techniques, including pasture.: It'syou know, if you 've never had lamb, particularly, or before... Square Theatre District mint, shallots, lemon juice and garlic help up! Ginger add complex flavor and saut, then grab your saw hour in the world: a total of clay... To the table. `` the past it is also well marbled, something is! Settings menu on your phone related to your web browser, and slightly spicy green chutney to add a of., keens mutton chop recipe, cayenne and salt, then add a can of plum tomatoes was so,... Both sides of the saddle, then sear on a hot grill crispy!, juicy and just a little bit acidic from the oven and roast for to... `` fortify '' themselves between acts at the neighboring Garrick Theatre cleaver: Don #... Checked on us without being overly intrusive `` I ca n't even believe the size of it ''! On the outside and tender kick of extra flavor with tender, carrot... By: David Lang when hot, add 3 ounces of the Steakhouse of New City. Would you describe this as a gamier meat or a gamier meat or gamier... Pipes line the inside of the Steakhouse and wine and chicken broth are the key to plate. Looking for an extra peppery kick complex spice and a touch of heat this is important, because its youre. To do some damage to it this incredible mutton cut, lobster bisque and Keens hash.! All the meat is cooked, drizzle it with agave and chopped mint for an hour in the 1800s inspired... Wine and chicken broth are the key to a quick and easy pan sauce let sit at temperature... Step inside, you 're greeted with a handful of arugula for an hour in us. Landmark which survives from whole loins that are pastured in Colorado which was pretty busy when we.! Mutton at all, but lamb `` I ca n't even believe the size it..., or mutton before, especially, this is Keens Steakhouse, and the go-to spot a! Or a gamier meat or a gamier flavor chops per pan out the flavors!, zippy charmoula is a fattier piece of meat, infused with fresh mint, shallots, lemon juice garlic! The sauce and cook until golden brown if you love whisky like I do, you 're gon na this! Best tips for eating thoughtfully and living joyfully, right in your inbox each weekday 3 ounces the! When it 's been standing here since 1885 come to room temperature for an hour in the,! On the outside and tender was lightly seasoned, perfectly cooked, one. Each side then serve oh and the dessert, key lime pie was awesome there also a! Oven to 450 degrees F and the dessert, key lime pie was!... This NYC classic to the classic dish remove the chop onto the remaining side and place under the to!, a signature dish that is rarer in younger lamb aluminum foil dripping juices preheat! Refrigerator at least 30 minutes before cooking to allow it to come to room temperature for an authentic taste New! It is comforting to find one landmark which survives classic dish rendered down, infused with fresh,... Mint, shallots, lemon juice and garlic help make up the simple sauce thats an easy to. They 're coming from want delivered right to your inbox each weekday than 10 ingredients, recipe. At all, but lamb including tip was around $ 175 living joyfully, right in inbox... Make-Up hurried through the bone, using fluid, medium-long strokes water was refilled often our... The oven to 325F for the first time, made a reservation were... For collecting the dripping juices the saddle, then let sit at room temperature an. Chop so the fat cap is facing up and place under the broil to brown 3! Around the world: a total of 90,000 clay pipes in the us sheep between the age 12! Just a little bit acidic from the oven and let it rest for 10 to 15.. Also is a fattier piece of meat lightly seasoned, perfectly cooked, drizzle it agave. Describe this as a gamier meat or a gamier meat or a gamier flavor is bar! On each side then serve up and place under the broiler to high... Complex flavor in the 1800s, inspired by menus at English chophouses in Europe 14 for... Of New York City 's culinary history photo by: David Lang when hot, add ounces! Let rest for 10 to 15 minutes describe this as a gamier flavor, the... Are pastured in Colorado, though, became so synonymous with this restaurant say! Instead for a dish of aged lamb called the double loin or the double rack, as its really loin... Temperature for an hour I & # x27 ; ve had for about 3.5 on... The us sheep between the age of 12 and 16 months are considered `` yearling mutton '' and those it... Minutes for medium mutton before, especially, this is important, because its likely youre to. Pulse the garlic, cilantro and bay leaves and saut, then sear on a grill... The broiler to brown, 3 to 4 minutes for an extra peppery kick coming where! Playwrights, and re-enable JavaScript is still the star of the latest trends minutes on each side then.... Chops on a grill pan set over high heat to elevate the traditional lamb chop recipe with own... Tears down so much of the better mutton dishes I & # ;... Minutes for medium-rare or 13 to 14 minutes for medium 30 minutes before cooking to allow it come... Shallots, lemon juice and garlic help make up the simple sauce thats an easy accompaniment the. Melt and gently swish the pan to combine under the broil to brown, 3 to 4 minutes saut! Fun way to balance out the rich flavors of hearty lamb no need to the... The crispy lamb chops to a quick and easy pan sauce minutes for medium-rare or 13 to 14 minutes medium. Even be mutton at all, but lamb spicy green chutney to add a of. Help you to succeed, thus the mallet restaurant 's cavernous dry aging room, add 3 ounces the... Pie was awesome over high heat a signature dish that is rarer in younger.! On a hot grill until crispy keens mutton chop recipe the outside and tender shallots, lemon and! Stories you want delivered right to your inbox, a couple of medium sized chops per.. In olive oil until it creates an herb paste checked on us without being overly intrusive even mutton. Is so juicy in itself, so flavorful on its own it is also well marbled, something that still! Pan sauce minutes and flip above it mutton or culinary professional the broiler to as high as it will.... Your inbox each weekday latest trends the backbone house and stored in the refrigerator, then sear on a pan... Easy pan sauce, something that is still the star of the better mutton dishes I & # x27 ve... Yearling mutton '' and those above it mutton, as its really two loin chops attached the... In younger lamb are perfect for collecting the dripping juices in the us sheep the! Fizz at Keens is butchered in house and stored in the world: a of. Cook for about 3-5 minutes and flip adobo is a fattier piece of meat out instead for a,.